DraftBuddy.com

Fantasy Baseball and Fantasy Football Draft Tools

  • Member Login
  • Register

     

  • Fantasy Baseball
  • switch to Fantasy Football
  • Draft Buddy
  • LPP
  • Rankings
  • Articles
  • News
  • Stats

Avoid Drafting Bryce Harper In The Top 10

March 19, 2018 By avanfossan 1 Comment

Is Bryce Harper a Top 10 fantasy asset for the 2018 season? Andy VanFossan says the risk-reward of Harper isn’t worth that price.

Most fantasy baseball drafts start with Mike Trout or Jose Altuve going first, followed by Clayton Kershaw or Nolan Arenado. Pick number five is where things can get interesting. There are a lot of different ways to go: Mookie Betts, Charlie Blackmon or Paul Goldschmidt, maybe Trea Turner, Giancarlo Stanton or another pitcher in Chris Sale.

Lets say you are drafting about the tenth spot and the bulk of these guys are gone. You might start thinking about adding outfielder Bryce Harper. His current average draft position in National Fantasy Baseball Championship (NFBC) drafts is 10th. However, I advise against drafting Harper. Top ten is too rich for the risk and reward of Harper.

Is Harper a superstar? Absolutely. Can he get hot and carry a team? He’s done it before, in the regular season and in the postseason. But can he play 150 games? That is where I have a hard time putting him in the top ten of a fantasy draft.

Since coming to the big leagues at age 19, Harper has played in 153 games or more only once, his MVP year in 2015. Since then he’s averaged only 129 games played. He has yet to drive in over 100 runs and has only hit over 40 home runs one time in his career – also in his MVP season.

Below is a 162 game average, based on Harper’s six years in the big leagues (source: Baseball Reference).

G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI
162 688 581 107 166 31 4 32 89
SB CS BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+
13 6 96 140 0.285 0.386 0.515 0.902 140

Not too shabby. The problem though is that it hasn’t happened yet. The key number here is 162. Harper hasn’t been able to reach that number on a consistent basis.

Harper projects 98 RBI and 35 HR per Steamer, which rank him 8th and 10th respectively in those categories. This puts him behind players like Goldschmidt, Manny Machado, Rhys Hoskins, Cody Bellinger and Khris Davis.

Before you start saying, “but those guys have lower averages and don’t score as many runs as Harper does,” give me a minute. This next part is what may seal the deal on why he shouldn’t be drafted in the top ten.

Power is quickly becoming a constant in baseball. Last year, 117 players hit over 20 home runs. However, only 16 players had over 20 stolen bases. If we cross reference how many players hit 20 home runs and stole 20 bases, only eight players were able to accomplish this feat: Altuve, Betts, Trout, Tommy Pham, Will Myers, Elvis Andrus, Brett Gardner and Andrew Benintendi.

There were a number of players like Goldschmidt, Byron Buxton and Whit Merrifield, among others, who were one or two home runs or stolen bases away from the 20/20 club. Harper is down the list with only 9 projected SB, so while power is great, it isn’t as scarce a commodity that you want to pay such a high price for it in Harper, while sacrificing so much in steals.

Another factor involved with not taking Harper in the top ten is pitching available and demanded. There are four “studs” that you can pretty much count on for 200 strikeouts, 15 plus wins and an ERA close to 3.25 – Kershaw, Sale, Corey Kluber and Max Scherzer.

When participating in mock drafts, I found that these four pitchers typically all go in the top 15. If you take one of these four pitchers, you get more bang for your buck than taking Harper in the first round. These four pitchers, and a host of less risky position players mentioned earlier, push Harper down to about the 15th best player available.

A final factor to take into consideration is the depth of Harper’s position. The outfield position isn’t as deep as it used to be, say compared to third base, but there are still a multitude of outfielders you can take instead of Harper and come out with a solid team.

For example, an outfield with Aaron Judge will cost you about 50 points in batting average and two stolen bases. That first pick could instead go towards a third baseman (Arenado, Bryant), a five category first baseman (Goldschmidt), a stud pitcher (Kershaw, Sale), a five category second baseman (Altuve) or a couple of better options in the outfield (Betts, Stanton).

Harper is going to have a good year. His career numbers show that already, plus the fact he’s in a walk year adds a little to my gut wanting to draft this guy. However, his track record of games played per year and his numbers compared with his fellow outfielders aren’t overwhelming. Do yourself a favor and pass on Harper unless he becomes a true bargain in the mid-second round or later.

Filed Under: Fantasy Baseball

  • Top Baseball News
  • Jose Abreu Tests Positive For COVID-19 Show More

    Chicago White Sox first baseman and 2020 American League MVP Jose Abreu has tested positive for COVID-19 and will be away from the team for the next several days. General manager Rick Hahn said that Abreu is "completely asymptomatic" and "frustrated." The 34-year-old slugger is in his eighth season with the White Sox and is expected to be the centerpiece of the team's powerful lineup after he hit .317 with 19 home runs and led the major leagues with 60 RBI in the shortened 2020 season. The three-time All-Star had some mild symptoms last month but should be just fine. Fantasy managers should expect Abreu to be ready for Opening Day. His current 36 ADP shows that the fantasy community isn't expecting another MVP-caliber season in his age-34 season.

    Feb 24 · RotoBaller White Sox Jose Abreu
  • Cody Bellinger Expected To Be Ready For Opening Day Show More

    Los Angeles Dodgers outfielder Cody Bellinger (shoulder) is expected to be ready for Opening Day, according to manager Dave Roberts. Bellinger underwent shoulder surgery in November after injuring it in the final game of the World Series, but it wasn't expected to limit him at all entering the 2021 season. After winning the National League MVP in 2019 when he hit .305/.406/.629 with a career-high 47 home runs, 115 RBI and 15 stolen bases, Bellinger failed to replicate those lofty numbers when he hit just .239/.333/.455 with 12 homers, 30 RBI and six steals in 56 games over the shortened 2020 season. Despite the down season, the left-handed slugger only saw slight regression in his strikeout and walk rates, so he could easily bounce back this year. Draft him as a strong No. 1 fantasy outfielder with a high floor in the second round.

    Feb 23 · RotoBaller Dodgers Cody Bellinger
  • Spencer Torkelson Impresses In Batting Practice Show More

    Detroit Tigers first baseman/third baseman Spencer Torkelson, the team's top prospect per MLB Pipeline, put on a show in batting practice at spring training on Monday during the team's first full-squad workout. Torkelson will get his first look at live pitching on Tuesday, and he could see quite a few at-bats when spring training games actually begin with Jonathan Schoop, Renato Nunez, Isaac Paredes, Victor Reyes, Nomar Mazara and Aderlin Rodriguez unlikely to be cleared to join camp until at least the weekend. Torkelson will work exclusively at third base in camp, unless the Tigers need an emergency first baseman. The 21-year-old slugger is a consensus top-10 overall prospect entering the 2021 season and is a must-own in dynasty/keeper leagues for his plus-plus power and hitting skills.

    Feb 22 · RotoBaller Tigers Spencer Torkelson
  • Brewers In The Mix For Jackie Bradley Jr. Show More

    The Milwaukee Brewers are one of about half a dozen other teams that seem to be considering free-agent outfielder Jackie Bradley Jr., Jon Heyman of MLB Network reports. Bradley is reportedly seeking a contract of more than four years and $50 million. Bradley is now 31 years old and is not going to develop the power/speed many foretold when he was younger. With that being said, his defense is elite and should keep him in contention for playing time. If the Brewers were to land Bradley, he'd likely be a platoon/bench player and likely wouldn't be relevant in terms of fantasy production.

    Feb 22 · RotoBaller Brewers Jackie Bradley Jr.
  • Jarred Kelenic To Start The Year In Minors Show More

    Seattle Mariners president and CEO Kevin Mather said that outfield prospect Jarred Kelenic will start the 2021 season in the minor leagues after Kelenic and his representation rejected the team's six-year contract extension offer with options. "We would like him to get a few more at-bats in the minor leagues, probably Triple-A Tacoma for a month. Then he will likely be in left field at T-Mobile Park for the next six or seven years, and then he'll be a free agent," Mather said. The No. 4 prospect in all of baseball, per MLB Pipeline, was frustrated that he wasn't called up last season after he hit .291/.364/.540 at High-A and Double-A in 2019 in 117 games while hitting 23 home runs and driving in 68 runs. While Seattle will hold him back a little longer to manipulate his service time, Kelenic should be a starting outfielder for the M's for the majority of the 2021 season.

    Buddy Take I recently added Kelenic as my fifth OF at pick 221 in a 10-team, best ball points league. That is right about bang on his NFBC ADP.

    Feb 21 · RotoBaller Mariners Jarred Kelenic
  • All Baseball News
    • Fantasy Baseball
      • Draft Buddy Software
      • Last Player Picked
      • Rankings
    •  
      • Articles
      • News
      • Stats
    • Fantasy Football
      • Draft Buddy Software
      • Rankings
      • Projections
    •  
      • Articles
      • News
      • Stats
    Draft Buddy
    Member Updates · Facebook icon Facebook · Twitter icon Twitter

    Copyright © 2021 Draft Buddy • Privacy Policy